Skip to content
IN-STORE SHOPPING CURRENTLY NOT AVAILABLE
LOCAL CURBSIDE PICKUP IS AVAILABLE
WE SHIP WORLDWIDE DAILY
1 YEAR WARRANTY INCLUDED ON ALL REFURBISHED ITEMS
IN-STORE SHOPPING CURRENTLY NOT AVAILABLE
LOCAL CURBSIDE PICKUP IS AVAILABLE
WE DO SHIP WORLDWIDE DAILY
1 YEAR WARRANTY INCLUDED ON ALL REFURBISHED ITEMS

Plush Toys for Sale

Welcome to our delightful Plush Toys collection, where cuddles and cuteness collide! 🧸

Indulge in a world of softness and charm with our adorable range of plush companions. Whether you're looking for a snuggly friend to accompany you on adventures or a comforting buddy to hug at night, we've got you covered. 

Here's why our Plush Toys collection is a must-have:

- Soft as a cloud: Each plush toy is crafted with the softest materials to ensure maximum huggability.

- Variety galore: From cute animals to magical creatures, there's a plushie for every personality and preference.

- Perfect for all ages: Whether you're young or young at heart, our plush toys bring joy to everyone.

- Ideal gifts: Surprise your loved ones with a gift that's as heartwarming as it is adorable.

Experience the magic of our Plush Toys collection today and bring home a new fuzzy friend to brighten your days! 🌟

Filters

$
$
Beanie Bellie - Randi the Rottweiler - 8" Small - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Randi the Rottweiler - 8" Small

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

A sweetheart for sure. Made with super soft VelveTy fabric Uniquely shaped, sitting in an attentive pose Includes official Ty Heart with birthday a...

View full details
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Mitzi the Cat - 5" Clip - Premium Plush - Just $4.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Mitzi the Cat - 5" Clip

$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
$5.24
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24

Beanie Bellie Mitzi is sure to be a purrific friend. Poised in sitting position, this cool cat is ready for anything, you can even tilt her head! T...

View full details
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
$5.24
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Lloyd the Leopard - 13" Medium - Premium Plush - Just $10.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Lloyd the Leopard - 13" Medium

$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54

Lloyd the leopard is fast, but not as fast as we say "AWW" when we see this Bellie! Lloyd is hunting for their next friend to explore with. Is that...

View full details
$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Duncan the Brown Bear - 13" Medium - Premium Plush - Just $10.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Duncan the Brown Bear - 13" Medium

$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54

Duncan has arrived to give a whole new meaning to bear hug! Always grinning from ear to ear, an embrace will surely turn your frown upside down. Ju...

View full details
$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Lillibelle the Pink Cat - 13" Medium - Premium Plush - Just $10.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Lillibelle the Pink Cat - 13" Medium

$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54

This kitty puts the PURR in purrity in pink! Lillibelle is the sweetest, fluffiest cat with the cutest tail you've ever seen. Just look at those te...

View full details
$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Izzy the Dog - 5" Clip - Premium Plush - Just $4.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Izzy the Dog - 5" Clip

$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
$5.24
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24

Izzy is a pug you will love to snuggle. When Izzy is not dozing, this little snuffler loves to eat and play. Add this cute pug to your collection t...

View full details
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
$5.24
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Crispin the Gingerbread Belly - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Crispin the Gingerbread Belly

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

This gingerbread man is a little spice and everything nice. Crispin is sure to be on Santa's good list, so make sure you add him to your list too! ...

View full details
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Bumper the Pink Hedgehog - 13" Medium - Premium Plush - Just $10.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Bumper the Pink Hedgehog - 13" Medium

$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54

Some people call hedgehogs pincushions with legs, but Bumper is the softest hedgie you will meet. This hedgehog has a long snout for sniffing and c...

View full details
$12.59
$12.59 - $12.59
$12.59
$11.54
$11.54 - $11.54
$11.54
Sold out
Beanie Bellie - Ace the German Shepard Dog - 5" Clip - Premium Plush - Just $4.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Bellie - Ace the German Shepard Dog - 5" Clip

$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
$5.24
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24

More than just the best guard dog around, Beanie Bellie Ace is your new favorite adventure buddy. Sitting attentively and following your lead, how ...

View full details
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
$5.24
$5.24 - $5.24
$5.24
Sold out
Beanie Baby Bellies - Mango Gold Striped Cat - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby Bellies - Mango Gold Striped Cat

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

Meow, I am Mango! It is a pleasure to meet you. I am a very energetic cat, but I also love lounging around the house soaking up the sun. Add me t...

View full details
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Teddy II - Blue Bear - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Teddy II - Blue Bear

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Teddy sits upright. All blue body with colorful ribbon "scarf." Surface clean only. Ages 3+

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Valentino II - PinkTeddy Bear - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Valentino II - PinkTeddy Bear

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Valentino is an adorable white bear with literal red heart! Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Scarlett II - White Teddy Bear - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Scarlett II - White Teddy Bear

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Scarlett II sits upright and features the TY heart. Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Snort II - Red Bull - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Snort II - Red Bull

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Snort II lays flat and features a red body with with yellow feet, nose, and horns. Ages ...

View full details
$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Zip II - Black & White Cat - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Zip II - Black & White Cat

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Zip II lays flat and features a black body, with white features, & a pink nose. Ages...

View full details
$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Squealer II - Pink Pig - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Squealer II - Pink Pig

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Squealer lays on their belly with a very sincere expression. Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Patti II - Orange Platypus - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Patti II - Orange Platypus

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Patti II lays flat and features an orange body with blue feet and bill. Ages 3+ Surface ...

View full details
$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Signature II - Mint Green Bear - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Signature II - Mint Green Bear

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Signature II sits upright and features the TY heart and signature. Ages 3+ Surface clean...

View full details
$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Quacker Jax II - Orange Duck - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Quacker Jax II - Orange Duck

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Quacker Jax II sits upright and features the TY heart. Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Peace II - Yellow Bear - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Peace II - Yellow Bear

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Peace II sits upright and sports a very stylish scarf. Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Peanut II - Purple Elephant - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Peanut II - Purple Elephant

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Peanut lays on his belly with a very sincere expression. Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$15.74
$15.74 - $15.74
$15.74
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Fredrick the Tie Dyed Fox - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Fredrick the Tie Dyed Fox

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

Made with soft VelveTy fabric, Frederick can be a sly fox but he wants to be your friend. Made with super soft Ty Silk fabric Classic animal styles...

View full details
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Baltic the Dog - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Baltic the Dog

$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

Curl up beside Baltic with his super soft VelveTy. Add this grey and white husky to your collection. Made with super soft Ty Tip Dyed fabric Classi...

View full details
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out
Beanie Baby - Cherub II - Pink Monkey - Premium Plush - Just $6.99! Shop now at Retro Gaming of Denver
Sold out

Beanie Baby - Cherub II - Pink Monkey

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34

The classic Beanie Babies are back! Very limited quantity. Cherub II sits upright and features the TY heart. Ages 3+ Surface clean only.

$10.49
$10.49 - $10.49
$10.49
$7.34
$7.34 - $7.34
$7.34
Sold out